Lagos mega city: Beyond
dreams
By CHRISTIAN OCHIAMA, SEUN ADESIDA and PETER ANOSIKE
Monday, April 28, 2008
|
•Fashola
Photo:
Sun News Publishing |
| |
“Lagos is going to become the fourth mega city in the
whole world in the coming years. We are already about the
sixth in position and we will get there.” These were
the words of the Lagos State Commissioner for Physical and
Urban Planning, Francisco Bolaji Abosede.
To achieve this, his counterpart in the Economic Planning
and Budget Ministry, Mr Ben Akabueze, said that the sum of
N7 trillion was needed for infrastructure development alone.
This makes the N117 billion the Union Bank of Nigeria Plc
and a Chinese Group are sourcing for the state look like a
small drop in a mighty ocean.
But not to worry, Abosede assured and added that the state
government had decided to “take the step due to the
desire to enable the state has a beautiful mega city”.
Elaborating on the practical steps already taken by the government,
he said, “we have been all over the world and have seen
what is obtainable. Nigeria should be a paradise; Lagos most
especially is the showpiece, the centrepiece of Nigeria.”
To be the real showpiece, old things must go away for all
things to become new. That might explain the demolition exercise
going on around the metropolis now. Abosede admitted so much
and added that, “we are demolishing, yes, but we do
not just demolish for the sake of it. It is because we want
to improve.”
Akabueze concurred and added that the N7 trillion will be
used to “build new infrastructure and upgrade aging
ones to meet the demands of the mega status of the city.”
The banker-turned-public servant said that the state government
was uncomfortable with the recent classification of Lagos
as Africa’s second most expensive city and the 59th
in the world.
Sad as this situation is, Akabueze justified it thus: “Lagos
has a population growth rate of between six and eight per
cent as against the national average of 2.9 per cent.”
If this projection was sustained, he said by 2015, the population
of the area will be 25 million.
With its current population of 18 million, the chartered accountant
said that “the state still experiences a huge gap in
terms of infrastructure it needs and what is available.”
Continuing, Akabueze on whose shoulders the planning of the
state’s economy, rests observed, “the gap between
the infrastructural needs and availability is worsened by
the aging nature of what is available and the magnitude of
cost involved in replacement and renewal.”
Sounding optimistic, Akabueze said that the state government
was determined in its goal of making Lagos a world class city.
According to him, “our approach has been to frontally
confront these challenges to tackle infrastructure in such
sectors as water development, roads, drainage, power, Information
and Communication Technology (ICT) as well as transportation.”
In the meantime, there is a pervasive perception of Lagos
as an organised slum.To this extent, therefore, if Lagos was
to become the dreamed beautiful city, then it follows that
its slum notoriety must give way. Abosede blamed this perception
of Lagos on the people’s proclivity to disobey the law.
“Town planning laws have ever been in existence, but
people will never follow the law as they believe they can
wake up, build and develop without any plan,” he lamented.
For this group of people, the Physical and Urban Planning
commissioner said, “money carries the day. They just
wake up and go and build because they have money. But until
you start doing something as a control, something to say it
cannot continue, you may not be taken seriously.”
But is mega city as a development concept new? The January-March
2008 edition of the Lagos Organization Review, says ‘no’.
The concept, it continues , as well as the nature of mega
city is “very arbitrary and ever changing. The change
is dictated by many factors”, prominent of which is
population.
The review pointed out that “population concentration
was referred to and used to differentiate mega cities from
other big cities.”
If population were the only criterion, how is it that Rome
with just over one million inhabitants is referred to as a
mega city whereas cities like Chicago, London, Bombay became
candidates only when they attained or crossed the 10 million
figure of United Nations’ threshold?
For Lagos, population is an important criterion. But as the
land mass of the area known as Lagos becomes too congested
for the population size, expansion to adjoining state of Ogun
towards the Ibafo, Mowe, Ofada, Ota and Sango areas becomes
not only inevitable but also imperative. Before this, the
reclamation of swampy areas of Lekki had opened up and thrown
Epe, Badagry and Ikorodu into the mix.
According to Abosede, the immediate past governor of the state,
Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu laid the foundation for the mega
city project through an aggressive urban renewal that transformed
Lagos with the emergence of central business districts in
Ikeja, Lagos Island including Victoria Island and Ikoyi, complete
with network of roads and other social infrastructure befitting
the city as the economic hub of the nation.
Abosede continued, “in the whole of Yaba and Ebute-Metta,
all contracts for infrastructure have been awarded. People
will now go there and want to develop. Over 36 streets are
to be upgraded to Lagos Island status.”
The state government is aware of the challenges facing it
as it embarks on the arduous task of reinventing Lagos. Regardless,
and to demonstrate its seriousness, it has put in place the
Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project (LMDGP).
The agency’s function is essentially to “increase
sustainable access to urban services through investment in
critical infrastructure,” Governor Babatunde Fashola
said while launching the project.
He categorized the investment areas as infrastructure with
an estimated budget of $165.35 million. Public governance
and capacity building $5.95 million , urban policy and project
coordination $12.13 million. These will take care of drainage,
solid waste management, upgrading of slums, institutionalized
data driven planning and results monitoring of government
programmes and policies, public finance reforms to improve
budgeting and expenditure management, essentially for operations
and maintenance of infrastructure and support leadership development
programmes.
Similarly, urban policy will finance knowledge management
and communications to strengthen metropolitan policy dialogue
and public/private partnerships.
Considering the strategic importance of Lagos to the economic
well-being of the country should the job be left to the state
government alone?
Akabueze seemed to have answered this question in the negative
when he pointed out that the state government had “received
a N701 million grant from the Federal Government for the rehabilitation
of primary health centers in its local councils.”
Before this, the state government had received a $200 million
World Bank assistance towards the development of the state’s
infrastructure, public finance and capacity building as well
as urban policy and project coordination.
Justifying the N117 billion the Union Bank Plc and a Chinese
Group are raising for Lagos as partners in the infrastructure
development of the state, the Executive Director, Corporate
and International Banking, Mr Austen Obigwe, said that “Lagos
State has a history of continuity, of obeying and respecting
whatever contractual obligations the preceding government
has gone into. We see Lagos State as being highly credit worthy.
What we are trying to do is, our bank (Union) and a group
in China are launching a one billion dollar infrastructural
development fund which will be used in the state alone.”
According to him, “we will use it to fund projects in
Lagos State. We are doing that because we have confidence
in Lagos State. We believe in Lagos State.”
Obigwe affirmed that the credibility of Lagos State could
be judged by the fact that “even if another government
comes to power, because of the importance of the economic
activities in the state, the chances that whatever contractual
obligation the previous government has will be respected are
usually very high.”
But, is there really a mega city project on or is it all hype?
This was the main subject of an interview Fashola granted
Lagos Organization Review.
In it he said, “I think the first thing is to identify
and clear some seemingly grey areas and the first of these
is that there is no mega city project.”
According to him, the mega city project could be a hype “especially
when it is looked at in the context of some esoteric new emergent
or building plan.” As far as His Excellency was concerned,
“the mega city concept is a status, just as the status
we acquire as human beings.”
To that extend, therefore, Fashola said, “in the same
way that you have those incidences of status change, Lagos,
because of the population that we have, has fallen into the
benchmark of cities classified by the United Nations and their
Urban Development Agencies as mega cities and that benchmark
is 10 million people.”
The governor moved on to narrate the urgency in the need to
accelerate the rate of infrastructural, social and economic
development of Lagos. “We are 18 million people and
projected to become 25 million by the year 2015, thus, due
to become the third largest mega city after Bombay in India
and Tokyo in Japan.”
With this in view, he averred that the “status of mega
city carries certain incidents, because it is a consequence
of rapid, somewhat uncontrolled urbanization. You have more
people, so there is almost a continuous demand on government
for services and government is all about people. The challenge
for us, today, is to continue and at a very rapid rate to
do all that is within our power to position Lagos in such
a way that she can cope with the obvious challenges of that
new status of a mega city”.
This challenge, Fashola observed, has become even more pressing
because “unlike a city that has one million people,
10 million people need more buses, more roads, more houses,
more policemen to secure them to meet the police-to-citizen
ratio, more schools, more hospital beds. They need more capacity
to manage refuse, because the tonnage of refuse as a result
of human activities will increase and is increasing. Everything
that is necessary to make sure that the city does not implode
is a mega city project.”
No matter how much anyone may want to pretend, developing
Lagos to cope with the influx of people is a challenge enormous
in its immensity.
Fashola knows and understands this and that is why he has
earmarked a three-pronged approach to the issue. One, is Public-Private
Partnership. Two, is the expectation from the Federal Government
given the special position of the state as (a) a former federal
capital (b) as the epicenter of not just the nation’s
economic activity but also her social life (c) internally
generated revenue.
On public-private partnership, the governor said that it,
“offers the only realistic route to the actualization
of Nigeria’s potentialities.”
Narrowing it to Lagos State, he added, “we are determined
to show the light for others to find the way.”
The governor asserted that the opportunities for viable investment
in Lagos State are practically limitless. Giving a brief insight
into the massive investment required to meet the infrastructural
challenges of Lagos State, Fashola said, “over the next
two decades, it is projected that the state must expend, at
least, $2billion over a five year period to provide a qualitative
and efficient road network.”
Describing as a crucial challenge the upgrading of existing
slums to uplift the quality of life of millions of men, women
and children, the governor further said that, “over
the next one and a half decades, no less than $185 million
would be needed.”
The governor cited power sector, waste management, transportation,
housing and security as other areas that deserved to be explored
through the public-private partnership.
However, he stressed that, “we are not extending a begging
bowl for charity or compassionate financial hand outs. No.
All we are seeking is serious minded investors who will utilize
our infrastructure challenges as opportunities to do profitable
business in Lagos State and Nigeria.”
Fashola, who served his pupilage in governance under Asiwaju
Tinubu as his Chief of Staff, in his quest for federal assistance
in the task of building the envisaged new Lagos, recalled
what the late Head of State, General Murtala Mohammed, said
when the idea was mooted for the relocation of the federal
capital from Lagos that “Lagos would not be abandoned
to the fate of coping with all the infrastructure and that
she should be declared a special status.”
The governor lamented that more than 30 years after that statement
was made, that pledge, because that is what it was, remained
unfulfilled. But he insisted that it must be discharged because
“it is not a favour to Lagos, it is a debt, an obligation.”
On a positive note, the governor observed that “we are
expecting about 30-35 per cent of our revenue to come from
the Federal Government, I have received some cooperation from
Mr President. I want more, certainly, and I am hoping that
this will continue.”
Still on the mode of execution of the mega city project, Fashola
said that part of the finance would be internally generated.
For instance, he pointed out that in the 2008 budget, “we
are going to raise 65-70 per cent of it on our own strength
and resources and that is why we are not letting off on taxation.”
Picking up the gauntlet dropped by Fashola, Nigeria’s
Financial Strategy 2020 Group is set to partner the Lagos
State government to establish an international financial center
in Lekki, Lagos State.
The scheme is being embarked upon as part of overall strategy
to fasttrack the evolution of an African financial center
in Nigeria. Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor, Professor
Chukwuma Soludo, who threw light on possible areas of such
collaboration at an interactive session with media executives
in Lagos, said that the center which would function under
a separate regulatory framework from that governing the conduct
of banking business in Nigeria required an enabling environment
enjoyed elsewhere to function.
He said that the FSS 2020 team would soon begin discussions
with the Fashola administration, to explore ways of making
the project a center of excellence. According to him, the
discussions will focus largely on provision of infrastructure,
effective transportation system, and such other components
that would make prospective users enjoy the kind of services
that obtain in more advanced countries.
He explained that the Lekki Financial Corridor will enable
its users conduct their business as if they were in London,
New York or Malaysia and, therefore, help in the nation’s
quest for full integration of the African financial market
with the rest of the world.
The CBN boss said the Financial System Strategy 2020 group
which is already working out modalities for the scheme’s
take off will be collaborating with the Lagos State government
to ensure the realization of the project.
On his part, the Group Managing Director of Dunlop Nigeria
Plc, Mr Mohammed Yinusa, reiterated the need for the Federal
Government and the organised private sector to partner with
the Lagos State government in addressing the infrastructure
challenge in the state.
He said it would be myopic to leave the challenges to the
state to singularly address, adding that the cost of the renewal
and development of infrastructure was far beyond the state’s
resources.
The Dunlop boss and co-chairman of the Lagos Economic Summit
Group (LESG), who said this recently remarked that the mega-city
challenge was a national responsibility, adding that with
a 25 million population coming in 2015, there was an urgent
need to expand the infrastructure base of the state.
But there are other reactions on the mega city project. Professionals
are worried that the emerging megacity might be a blessing
in disguise and, therefore, called for a cautious approach
to the project.
Chief Mike Campbell, an engineer, said that he had mixed feelings
over the mega city project. According to him, turning Lagos
to the world’s fourth mega city is a good dream and
a welcome development.
However, he said that right now, what should be uppermost
in the mind of Lagos State government should be how to decongest
the city instead congesting it the more, adding that that
was what turning Lagos into a mega city would come to at the
end of the day.
“If people in Asaba, Osogbo or Takum hear that all is
now well with Lagos in terms of infrastructure, they would
jump into the next bus and come to Lagos and before you know
it, the whole Nigeria is in Lagos. Government should think
of ways of de-centralizing economic and social activities
to the other areas. It is only when the other parts of the
country are developed and independent of Lagos that the dream
could be successful. Turning Lagos into a mega city will not
only attract people from the other parts of the country but
other African countries.”
Felix Oguejiofor, an Architect, said that Lagos was the fastest
growing city in the world but at the same time the least planned
of the major cities.
According to him, the ever-increasing population of the city
has led to social, political, economic and environmental problems.
For him, changing the face of Lagos from a jungle city to
a modern city should be seen as a step in the right direction.
“I don’t care the name they choose to call it
whether Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project
(LMDGP) or Lagos Mega City project. My concern is that Lagos
is due for complete turn around. The entire infrastructure
in the state is begging for face-lift, the refuse dumps have
filled to the brim. Everywhere is stinking. This, to me, is
as a result of corruption and neglect because in the 70’s,
the Lagos Master Plan was drafted with the intention of guiding
the ever-increasing population of the state into the 21st
century.
With the support of the UNDP, the master plan was meant to
provide a framework for addressing challenges concerning the
provision of housing, expansion of economic activity centers,
improvement of transportation, infrastructure and upgrading
of informal slums settlements.
According to the master plan, Oguejiofor said, “the
growing city was to be divided into 35 self-sufficient districts,
each with its commercial industrial and residential zones.
This beautiful master plan was abandoned. Had it been that
it was implemented, Lagos would have been the better for it.
That is why I doff my hat for the administrations of Bola
Ahmed Tinubu and his successor, Barrister Babatunde Raji Fashola
for resurrecting the master plan.
It was the abandonment of the master plan that made the planned
development of Lagos to go out of hand. Now, everybody has
become a lord unto himself in the state. This has made the
project to look like a crisis. The little injury then in the
60’s and 70’s that was left untreated has decayed
and become cancerous and the doctors are now battling to save
the life of the patient. The patient on the other hand is
resisting because it has got used to decay and cancer after
decades of abandonment.”
Ebenezer Oladiran, an estate surveyor and valuer said that
for the Lagos mega city project to work, a lot of things would
come into play. He said that infrastructure must be functioning.
According to him, the rail lines as well as road networks
would be effective.
His words: “You cannot talk of a mega city without efficient
road and rail networks. The rails would be developed to such
an extent that they will be major means of transportation
in the city. The rail lines must be cheap and very effective.
If you go to London or New York which are mega cities, rail
lines are the major means of transportation. Car owners prefer
parking their cars in their houses and going to their various
places of work in buses and trains.
So, efficient transportation system is one of the things that
should be put into consideration when talking about mega city.
Another thing is efficient police system. There should also
be efficient police system. The countries with mega cities
have developed efficient police system that they are able
to track down criminals in minutes. You can not think of a
mega city where the security system is not functioning.”
Oladiran said that the Lagos State Government should go and
study other mega cities to know why their system is working,
adding that it was not infrastructure alone that makes a town
mega city.
He said that putting all the infastructure in place without
political will would amount to nothing.
“Lagosians have been noted for lawlessness. This is
a city where people find it difficult to obey laws. So, apart
from the infrastructure, we also need political will to make
it work. We need attitudinal change and cultural reorientation.
So, mega city is not all about having six lane roads, airports
in every street, skyscrapers and beautifully painted houses.
We need political will to coordinate all the infrastructure.
If the government puts all the required infrastructure in
place and we don’t have the discipline to manage them,
they would all come to naught. Therefore, I feel that the
most important tool that we need to make the dream come true
is attitudinal change.
He said that the professionals in the construction industry
should be allowed to do their work.
According to him, the National Building Code has spelt out
the role of each professional in construction be it in road
or house construction.
|