CAUTION
Bandwagon probes could consume entire political class
– Sule Lamido
•Why I won’t probe Saminu
By Steve Nwosu and Taiwo Amodu
Saturday, May
10, 2008
 |
•Lamido
Pix: Sun News Publishing
|
| |
Members of the political class agitating for the probe of
the immediate past administration of Gen. Olusegun Obasanjo
have been urged to tarry awhile and exercise restraint as
such a probe could turn out to be a Frankenstein monster,
possibly devouring the entire political elite.
Speaking with SATURDAY SUN in Dutse, the Jigawa State capital
in an exclusive interview, the state governor and former Minister
of Foreign Affairs, Alhaji Sule Lamido, submitted that a thorough,
comprehensive and sincere scrutiny of what transpired under
the Obasanjo administration would leave ordinary Nigerians
stupefied and the entire political elite at the receiving
end of their anger because Obasanjo could not have done it
alone.
”You‘re talking about a leader of Nigeria who
was acting with a network of operators. I don’t think
this $16 billion (the amount expended on the IPP project)
is there in the account of Obasanjo… if we should go
through the whole hog, it would be the end of the entire Nigerian
elite. I’m sure by the time names begin to reel out,
you will be surprised who and who is involved.’
On his home state of Jigawa and the plundering that transpired
during the administration of his immediate predecessor, Saminu
Turaki (now facing corruption charges), Lamido disclosed that
the state is applying to be joined in the suit against Turaki,
“not really to criminalise the former governor but to
retrieve the oil block in his possession which he allegedly
bought with money belonging to the state.” . Excerpts:
Ethanol project: one big fraud
Yes, the previous government here pursued an ethanol project.
The ethanol project is an excellent project but the execution
was a design to perpetrate fraud. The concept was totally
at variance with the execution. There was this oil block which
was wrapped up as a deal to finance the ethanol project and
then, from what I’m hearing, it was also used in financing
third term.
This is what I heard. Because a government can’t own
an oil block, the former governor floated a personal company
and this oil block was bought.
Now, the problem is that he actually took government money
in paying for the oil block, using the ethanol thing as a
decoy. So, right now, the ethanol project is something which
I can’t really place my finger on. Part of what we’re
doing is, because Jigawa state money is there, we’re
now, in the course of the EFCC investigation asking that Jigawa
be joined, not to criminalise Saminu Turaki, but to retrieve
the oil block from him for Jigawa state, which we will then
sell and get the money.
So, by the time we go to court and fulfill the requirements,
we will retrieve the oil block. Then, whatever they do with
Saminu Turaki, that’s their own problem. So, by the
time we have this oil block and get our money, of course,
we can do a lot with the money.
I won’t probe Saminu, but…
You see, you are right that Jigawa is the biggest-hit, in
terms of this culture of monumental fraud, but then, for us,
you just don’t go simply arraigning people. Simply going
into investigation. What we did was through the transition
committee which we put in place. We asked them to give us
an assessment of what I was taking over.
Now, the committee was comprised of people, whose integrity
can’t be questioned by anybody in Nigeria. I think I’d
the most honorable transition committee in Nigeria. One of
them is an economist, another former ambassador, there’s
a former auditor-general of the state and so on. These are
people of reputation, people whose track records in public
service, whose public conduct nobody can question. These are
people who worked meticulously and gave me their findings
and part of their recommendations was that I should institute
another committee to verify or authenticate the various projects
in Jigawa, because we had projects worth over N74 billion
– various projects, ranging from boreholes to what have
you.
Only N3bn of N74bn contracts can be verified
Out of these projects of about N74billion, only N3billion
could be certified. Other projects have either not started
or have been abandoned. All the contractors were given a fair
hearing…they were told to come and address the committee
and most of them refused to come. Four companies took us to
court – four companies, who’re our own contractors,
given jobs to do by the then state executive council, under
some agreement crafted and dated by the ministry of justice
which they all signed, with provisions for resolving difficulties
or whatever it is.
But when we called them to come, they took us to court; that
we’ve no right to infringe on their human rights; that
we’re harassing them. And a judge in a High Court in
Kano gave injunction that they should not be called. We have
written a petition to the National Judicial Council against
the judge, because his action is despicable, both in law and
in morality, even though I am not a lawyer, I am only a politician.
But how can it not be when the companies in question, all
of them, belonged to the former governor and they’re
handling a contracts worth about N45 billion? And yet a High
Court Judge in Nigeria ruled that we can’t call such
a contractor to verify what he’s doing which he has
abandoned!
Take the case of this water borehole. The government then
was sinking at the cost of half a million per borehole and
we were going to sink motorized boreholes at N75 million per
unit. I think the cost of all these went to about N30 billion
or thereabout. The companies took about N10 billion and gave
a work worth only nine and half a million naira and yet we
can’t call the company to come and verify.
Because, instead of appearing before the committee to verify,
they went to court and there was a declaration that we can’t
call them, even though they’ve not gone back to work.
They have disappeared and we can’t trace them. One claims
to be in Hadejia, we went there, but they were nowhere. Even
in Abuja or Lagos, or anywhere. So, they couldn’t even
be traced with any address.
But we know the names of the directors and yet, a judge gave
a judgment that they shouldn’t be called.
Now, it is not that I don’t want to probe but that since
we have this report from this committee, the thing to do is
pick some areas which we think we can now treat. Because,
right now, of all the claims of liabilities, the committee
could only certify claims worth N3.5billion.
That’s what we’re paying and we’ll put it
in the budget. We can’t pay in one lump. We make sure
we put it in our budget in the middle or last quarter and
then send the appropriate bill to the House, and if they approve,
we then pay.
Getting the certified liabilities sorted out is my most immediate
challenge, not putting up a commission of enquiry, simply
because that’s the vogue in Nigeria – just to
generate sensation and entertainment which the typical Nigerian
believes in and enjoys. We are going to deny them that entertainment.
The records are there under seal, in our archives and also
in our banks and they will be there for life. So, any Jigawa
citizen is free to go to court over those things and demand
justice, because it’s their government. I’ve no
time for probe, because there’s so much to be done.
The state is already a ‘failed’ state. By the
time I begin to probe, then everybody will be writing the
obituary of the state: “here lies the remains of a state
which is probing its past but which certainly is sadly not
restored!” So, let me get the state restored first,
let’s get the institutions kick-started and working
first. Meanwhile, the records are there for life.
Anybody who wants, can go to court.
And there is something about these probes you are talking
about: If you go by the Nigerian mentality, after being entertained,
they’re also very, very humane. They’re very forgiving
and the Nigerian is also very, very emotional. After you might
have entertained him with all these accusations and then he’s
engulfed by pity and sympathy, he is the one who will say,
“leave him alone now!”
Look at the regime of Murtala Muhammed. After all those allegations
of frauds and confiscations, what happened? You look at those
towers along Ozumba Mbadiwe Road in Victoria Island and all
the property confiscated have been restored to their former
public officer owners - governors who, at that time, were
perceived by Nigerians as rogues, as crooks and were vilified
by the country, as Nigerians were being entertained by the
details of their misdemeanor. Some few years after, the same
Nigerian people of course, became very, very forgiving. Why?
And it has been going on over and over again, hasn’t
it?
Probe, a no-win case for me
Instituting a probe, will become a problem because whatever
I do will be interpreted one way or the other. Number one,
Saminu is in PDP--- he joined my party, we campaigned together.
Now, if I put up a probe and the probe says he didn’t
steal, they will say, “Ah! Didn’t we say it? Sule
‘chopped’ the money with him. He was part of it!!
If they find him guilty, they will say, Ah! We know Sule is
very, very vindictive. All along, he’s unforgiving’.
So, head or tail, I will lose.
So, I know what I’m doing and frankly speaking, the
regime of Saminu in the last eight years, should be seen as
part of the conspiracy of the entire Jigawa elite and people.
It’s to our collective failure at controlling or restraining
him that he was able to do what he did. So, the records are
there. I want the private prosecutor to go to court. Anybody
is free to go to court over these things.
The records are there under seal, under lock and key. They
cannot be stolen and they cannot be set on fire by anybody
because they’re in fireproof vaults. Even if you go
and put the place on fire, the vaults won’t catch fire.
So anybody who’s interested can take it up. For now,
I’ve no time to create tension, or division and - in
the process - giving room to political money makers who thrive
in crisis to make money out of government and out of those
who have been perceived to be the accused. We want peace and
luckily, we are getting the peace.
Why I won’t abandon Obasanjo
While every Nigerian and every politician, including those
who worked with former President Olusegun Obasanjo, vilify
him and treat him as a political leper, Lamido explains why
he would not join the fray.
“You see, I worked with Obasanjo for four years and
I regard myself as part of what he did between 1999-2003 as
a government. That government, as far as I know, was absolutely
on course. At least, within our foreign Ministry. I knew we
were on course. We were doing what was right.
Within that space that I served Obasanjo, within those first-four
years, I’d defend him anywhere. There are a number of
things in our foreign policy which I did and he supported
it. More than anything else, he restored Nigeria as a very,
very strong leader in the context of race and development.
His message was very clear: that whatever we may be, we could
not take anything which would make us seem subordinated.
I think he made a very profound statement on western hypocrisy
which, of course, offended even his Western friends. There
was a time Obasanjo told them, something like, “look,
when we are talking about retrieving our looted money, you
talk about difficulty placed by your laws in giving these
money back to us. But there are no difficulties in your laws
getting this money into the banks in your country from our
country. I find your laws illogical, if it encourages pillage
and plundering and corruption”. He told them to their
face that they were contradicting their advocacy for human
rights because taking looted monies to enhance and support
their own economies which means depleting our own treasury
have dire consequences on the quality of life. And that there
was no way anyone could talk about democracy if there was
no prosperity and there’s no way you can guarantee prosperity
if there’s no money to sustain it because the money
we need for that kind of service to our own people is there
locked up in European banks, to better their own economy and
the life of their people. He said, “Now, we need the
money, you say there’s a difficulty”.
So, these were the kind of things we did in our first four
years, and we restored our pride, our honour and dignity and
Obasanjo was very good at that. After I left, I have no idea
of what he did. I heard it for the first time, only last week
when the committee on power probe came here, saying that there
are four independent power projects in Jigawa State worth
billions of naira. The money has been taken and the contractor
doesn’t even know where Jigawa is on the Nigerian map,
not to talk of going to site.
OBJ didn’t do it alone …
So, I’m saddened. But then again, you see, being a governor
now, I know what it’s all about. The government defines
the general direction of policy and then designs programmes,
get them authorized as contracts and give them out. But who’re
the operators? So, what happened to the contractors who are
Nigerians, the ministers, the advisers and so on?
So, though the revelations are painful and I don’t condone
what might actually have happened. But again, we must see
beyond the personae of Obasanjo and go beyond the Nigerian
passion to vilify. I was just trying to tell you the way Nigerians
behave when the tide is against you. We all swim in the ocean
of emotions and nobody sees clearly. Look at the case of the
Emir who stripped Obasanjo of his title. Here is a retired
General who served under Obasanjo, who became a traditional
ruler, who conferred on Obasanjo a title, for whatever reasons
but I don’t think Obasanjo ever applied to the Zuru
Kingdom to be made a title holder. Then you see the way he
is trying to shame Obasanjo in his own way. I mean, there
should be some decorum in our life for God’s sake! We
must set some standards of official and unofficial justice
in the way we judge issues and events.
I feel sad that we convict a person, before even trying him
and you’re talking about a former leader of Nigeria
who certainly operated with a network of operators. I don’t
think this $16 billion is there in the account of Obasanjo.
Although, as the president, he’s liable, he’s
answerable even if it were that he had listened to wrong advisers,
wrong ministers, wrong operators but it is important to note
that he picked them from the Nigerian environment. I think
all those involved should be publicly mentioned and publicly
shamed and of course, arraigned, if found guilty convicted.
We should go through the whole hog and it would be the end
of the entire Nigerian elite, because I’m sure by the
time names begin to reel out, you’ll be surprised who
and who is involved. Now, I’m not really condoning whatever
might have happened during Obasanjo last four years. I never
believed in third term. He knew it. He was aware of that.
We never discussed it. I spoke openly against third term and
the tapes must still be there in AIT but I don’t believe
he sat there alone and was doing all these things. Who are
the other actors? I think its imperative for all Nigerians
to do his own bit right, do his own portion correctly whenever
given the opportunity to serve.
Restoring Jigawa
Well, you see, the state was declared as the poorest by the
CBN and, I think, some international agencies that have been
working here and collected all the indices. By their assessment,
based on what they have seen physically, they came by that
declaration that it’s a sorry state of affairs. So,
coming here as governor always reminded me of the difficulties
I always encountered in marching on in life and this started
very early. Imagine a Fulani boy, a cattle rearer, you know,
who lived all his times in the bush – under rain, under
sunshine, rearing cattle, suddenly having to go to school.
Imagine the shock of leaving that environment of birth, my
village, then the shock of trekking some miles from my village.
It was a journey to a totally new world altogether, because
I thought, and you may not believe it, that my village was
the only and the best place in the world.
Honestly, when I left village for my primary school (Government
School Birnin Kudu (a boarding primary school), I faced some
difficulties. I couldn’t speak Hausa. So I had to cope
with more difficult learning process: first of the language,
and then the academics.
So, early in life, I had been exposed to confronting difficulties.
At home, I was comfortable as a village boy but then I had
to go to school, trek there, learn the dominant language and
coping with the academics then go to Barewa College, enter
world of work, become a politician and end up as a foreign
affairs minister. Of course, as a foreign minister, you can
imagine what I have seen in my life. You can imagine what
I have seen in my life – to come from that kind of background
and then go into dealing with issues at the global level.
So, all these gave me a very, very clear ground on which I
can make a fair adjustment on what is called development.
So, this contrast of having seen the extreme of everything
in life: the life in my village which is of toiling everyday
to live, where life is pure agony and anguish and poverty,
to the extreme of comfort and prosperity which I saw and enjoyed
out there, has had a profound effect on me in terms what can
I do for my people. Sometimes I look up to God and ask, why
did I attempt to govern this state? Because, one, there are
no resources; two, the institutions have collapsed; three,
the people (even though they are very hardworking, industrious),
they have to be motivated, because they have been switched
off and they have to be switched on – even to attend
to basic, routine things. So, I don’t think there’s
some kind of parameter, but then you see, it’s like
simply discovering myself in this environment which I think
has no bearing with what I call standard life anywhere in
the world.
Taking beggars off the streets
We did not make any law banning beggers from the streets in
Dutse. No! You see, every human being has an inherent sense
of decency and dignity. It’s conditions to which they’re
exposed which took away their sense of human dignity and self-esteem
and they go to a level which is subhuman. But when the environment
and the leadership and people are prepared, to be humane,
to be caring and compassionate, then you restore in them their
sense of decency, their sense of honor, their sense of dignity.
Simple.
So, there’s no law which says beggars shouldn’t
be on the streets in Jigawa State but the fact that they’ve
seen us as making efforts to address their most basic needs
has simply restored in them their self pride, self respect
and dignity. So, while our stipend is supporting them, it’s
also restoring in them the feeling that they’re part
of the human society and not unwanted. Of course, they’re
still very poor but the environment is now caring and sensitive
to them.
No amount too much to develop humanity
When you talk about how much is leaving government coffers,
there’s no amount of expenditure which is too much to
develop human beings, to cater for human beings. What’s
the money for? What is it there for?
Imagine you being blind, you being crippled, and you’re
in the middle of an inferno. While the animals would simply
run away you stay there and roast because of your disability.
So, you must look at the deep feeling, the deep meaning of
human being denied some physical attributes which you take
for granted. It’s simply because over the years, our
norms, our traditions, our values have been so distorted that
the aberrations have become the norms. It is this rush for
contest, this materialism that has blinded us to our sense
of social duty. So, you see a lot of people who are in this
society – former governors, senators, ministers, whose
life after leaving office, you’ll be surprised
Fine, they made the money, but you find that after a few years
of grandstanding and fooling themselves, they simply evaporate.
They find it difficult to reintegrate into the society, because
the money appropriated is finished. Most of us are simply
being clever by half. That’s all. So, there’s
nothing which I think is too much to support these people.
If we help our people - their level of education, their health
- they become more productive. And because they’re productive
they tend towards civility- they don’t even like crisis
or violence, because they feel responsible and they also want
to contribute towards peace and order in the environment..
Arresting Jigawa workers’ weekend drift to
Kano
The state, as I’ve been saying, was an unusual baby
when it was created. Normally, when a baby is born, after
all the pains of child labour, the mother carries the baby
and you can see the swelling of joy in her.
The father sees his new baby, you can see the tears of joy,
flowing. It’s something you can’t describe. But
when Jigawa was created, it was the only baby whose mother
was weeping tears of sadness because she was not happy with
what was produced. The father was also weeping, because he
was not happy with the baby produced.
So, nobody in Jigawa was really excited when the final configuration
of the state emerged. On the date it was pronounced, there
were a number of claims: Some were saying, it was a female,
others were saying, no it’s a male, some said it’s
crippled, there were those who insisted it had no ears –
all kinds of claims, because of the chemistry of the state.
Those who wanted it and fought for Jigawa were not in Jigawa
State (their towns did not fall within Jigawa boundaries);
those who would never have thought in their life that they
would be part of it, who fought for a separate state - based
on their own permutations - found themselves in Jigawa State.
So, the chemistry was just one huge cocktail with nothing
but bubbling crisis. So, with this kind of chemistry, it’s
been a huge task, huge challenge for the people and leadership
to blend this state and unfortunately for the citizenry, it
has been abandoned. All of us, including myself, we’ve
all abandoned the state. We only used it to make some claims
on the federation.
So, when I came, we met all our leaders – political,
religious leaders, those in private sector. To me they’ve
to be reached and in reaching them, you’ve to be genuine
and sincere in your mission. And they all came. But the journey
in Jigawa is a marathon journey, not a journey for sprinters.
It’s something which has to be systematic, something
which has to be clearly defined, understood and you put in
place the mechanism to be able to march forward. Because we
are encased and enclosed, we want to first bring out ourselves.
So, the government is making efforts to put in place decent
houses, to be able to accommodate some critical segments of
the workforce.
Now, with regards to the business community, they can only
come, when they see the incentives for profit. No matter what
you do, they will not come until they see something in terms
of facilities, in terms of the infrastructures, in terms of
the incentives, which will make them make profit. Go to Iraq,
they’re killing themselves and people are dying there
everyday, yet business people are there making brisk business.
So, the businessmen will only go and invest where they see
the opportunity to make profit.
So, I don’t fool myself. It’s for me to put the
enabling environment and you’ll see the ripple effects.
Reviving State owned Corporations
You see, if you take the Hadejia rice mill for example, floated
during the regime of the military administration, 15 years
ago, I think since the formal opening - with all the funfare
- nothing has been happening there. But it’s a huge
investment. In today’s globalizing economy, and the
position of Jigawa State in it, the truth is that we don’t
have the resources to fund the companies from the budget.
These are areas which the private sector should find it very
easy to take up, because they can make money out of it. So,
what we did was to put up a committee of elders, with seasoned
economists and financial managers to look at the situation.
The main finding of the committee was that Jigawa State, because
of the value of the Hadejia river, can really be an asset
for whatever you want to do in agriculture and we’re
talking with some companies outside Nigeria showing interests.
The companies have seen the commitment the government is showing
and in the next couple of months, there will be something
agreed upon. |