Naira:
The Soludo solution By Wale Sokunbi Wednesday,
August 22, 2007
Last week, the Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN),
Professor Chukwuma Soludo, rattled Nigerians in a way they have not been rattled
in a very long time. The steely but ever smiling champion of consolidation in
the banking industry hit Nigeria with news that will have far greater impact on
the people and the Nigerian economy than the recent bank consolidation programme,
which had also generated so much flaks and accolades, when it was first mooted
in July 2004.
The latest Soludo interjection involves a re-denomination
of the naira to restore its value “close to what it was in 1985 before the
commencement of the Structural Adjustment Programme in 1986.”
This
will involve the introduction of a new currency structure with N20 as the highest
denomination. The restructuring will see the current N1000 notes become N10, N500
becomes N5 and N100 becomes N1, through a shift of the decimal point two places
to the left to eliminate two zeros. By the re-denomination, a person on a salary
of N30,000 today will from August 2008, the effective date of the policy, go home
with N300 which, hopefully, will have the same value with the N30,000 he is presently
earning. N1.25 of the new naira denomination will exchange for 1 dollar, up from
the current N125 to one dollar.
The re-denomination of the currency is
expected to reduce the cost of production, distribution and processing of currency
in Nigeria, promote usage of coins and lay the foundation for the easy convertibility
of the naira to other currencies.
In essence, the idea is to strength the
naira to make it the currency of choice for the proposed singe currency for West
Africa as envisioned by the Economic Community of West African State (ECOWAS)
The intervention will also involve the sharing of part of the Federal Account
Allocation in US dollars to deepen the forex market and for liquidition management,
from September 2007.
As could be expected, the planned re-denomination
of the naira was received like an earthquake in the country. Even the Federal
Government and the Federal Executive Council gave the impression that it had no
idea or confidence in the planned re-denomination of the naira with the quick
announcement of a government team to study and finetune the details of the initiative.
From different parts of the country, commendations and condemnations have
been streaming out, from economists and market women alike.
While the
Action Congress (AC) has called for the sack of Soludo and other notable economists
have questioned the CBN initiative, chiefly because they believe the value of
the currency of a country cannot be increased by fiat when there has been no increase
in production, others have expressed confidence in the ability of the initiative
to restore value and confidence in the naira.
As strange as the idea of
the re-denomination of the naira seemed to many Nigerians when it was first announced
last week, emerging facts indicate that it is not as outlandish as the people
had thought. It is an option that has been used in many countries, including close
by Ghana which now has its cedis valued at about 97 cents.
It behooves
the nation therefore not to attack Soludo’s grand dreams for the naira but
patiently wait for the Central Bank to enunciate the modus operandi with which
it hopes to make the policy work in Nigeria before positions are taken on the
matter.
One issue which the CBN will also have to take into cognizance
is the peculiarity of the Nigerian economy and Nigerians themselves. The CBN can
expect to have a hard time and spend a lot of money to get the message of this
development down to the grassroots in every part of the country. Again, if
the change of the current N100 to N1 is easy to effect in the formal sectors like
the banks, in the Stock Exchange and with regard to salaries of people in paid
employment, it will be interesting to see how the reduction in prices of foodstuffs
and other commodities will be enforced, by exactly the same margin, in the open
market.
In essence, when the salary of a person on N30,000 now becomes
N300 after August 2008, how does the government hope to ensure that the cost of
a piece of meat in the roadside bukateria, now sold at N50, goes down to 50 kobo
and not N1? Or that a landlord reduces the rent of his house, accordingly? Let
us also consider the scenario of a worker who had expected to collect N10 million
as his gratuity on disengagement from service next year now to be paid N100,000.
How effectively can the CBN ensure that the N100,000 to be collected by that retiree
will be able to buy what he could have bought with the old N10 million?
These
examples aptly capture the tricky nature of the new Soludo gamble. It is a gamble
that could pay off beautifully, with a stronger naira that could be the single
currency for the entire West African zone. On the other hand, it could lead to
a crisis, a scenario that will take many Nigerians, including the hypothetical
retiree, down with it.
Ordinarily, one would have expected that the CBN
will be guided by the widely acknowledged view that the strength of a currency
is determined by the strength of the economy, its productive capacity, infrastructure,
security of lives and property, employment, good governance, and strict adherence
to the rule of law which enhance higher local productivity and increased capital
inflow through greater foreign investments and exports.
But I believe Soludo,
the dreamer, must have his facts right and is ready to stake his name, his career
and his future on this lifetime gamble. Instead of the discordant tunes coming
from different parts of the country, the way to go, I believe, is for the government
and our economists to clinically study this agenda and determine whether it is
the best for the nation or not.
If the naira is to go the Soludo way,
efforts must be made to ensure that the people, in every nook and cranny of the
country, are educated on the how the reforms will be effected and the gains to
us as a country, to induce the cooperation of all.
The impression that
is being created that the Federal Government and the Federal Executive Council
are divided on this matter, or that the Finance Minister, himself, until recently
a Deputy Governor of the CBN, is against it, will not help matters. All hands
have to be on deck so that the entire country is mobilized to make the new re-structuring
work.
One other area, however, for which Soludo owes the nation an explanation
is the restructuring of the naira and the introduction of new notes and coins,
at great cost to the country, just a few months ago, only for this proposal for
the notes and coins to be withdrawn for replacement with new ones next year? What
exactly is responsible for this? Is it a case of policy fatigue or is the impending
re-denomination just another brainwave that could be abandoned mid-stream again?
Answers to these questions will go a long way in winning the support of Nigerians
for this novel re-denomination exercise.
Beyond the outcry over the re-denomination,
however, is the need to salute the vision of Soludo and the courage which he has
brought to bear on his decisions as CBN governor. The planned re-denomination
of the naira is an audacious step that should be fully supported, once our financial
experts have taken their time to study it and are agreed that it is the best way
forward for Nigeria.
Whichever way the nation goes, it is imperative to
commend the CBN governor for his ability to think out of the box. It is thinking
and courage such as this that move societies forward.
|