ADVERTISEMENT
The Sun Nigeria
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
  • The Sun Foundation
No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
  • The Sun Foundation
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Nigeria
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Columns

A meritorious judge

24th May 2019
in Columns, Editorial
0
‘Toxic’ British Labour leader
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Much as they are envied and unappreciated largely owing to the misconduct of some of their reckless colleagues, two very demanding qualities of men on the bench are discretion and sacrifice. Without judges, anarchy portends. Yet, unlike other folks in society, judges, ideally, are more of recluses compared to fellow citizens. Yet, judges, no matter how discreet, may not entirely escape the fall-out of everyday life of their spouses and offspring.

This seemed to have been the lot of the erstwhile president of the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal, Justice Zainab Bulkachuwa, who had to withdraw following protests raised on her possible impartiality by counsel of the petitioner, former Vice President Atiku Abubakar. Remarkably, Justice Bulkachuwa withdrew not because the fear of impartiality against her was sustained. Indeed, the panel dismissed the allegation of possible political bias on account of being married to a senator elected on the platform of the All Progressives Congress, Muhammed Bulkachuwa.

Whichever way the ruling went, there was bound to be controversy. Justice Bulkachuwa, therefore, had to voluntarily withdraw so that justice would be seen to have been done. That was meritorious. At their level, especially in these days of a tainted judiciary, such judges do not emerge easily. And there was no way Justice Bulkachuwa could have remained on the panel without playing into the hands of malicious critics. On the other hand, the judge’s withdrawal has enhanced the potential credibility of the tribunal.

The ruling of the tribunal itself is monumental. At the appropriate or chosen time in life, a judge must get married, a human obligation or desire, which is neither an offence nor an indiscretion. The danger now is that, henceforth, judges finding themselves in Justice Bulkachuwa’s shoes will be vulnerable to such naturally circumstantial protests. Lawyers call such citation authority.

Yet, no judges of whatever gender could ever foresee the involvement of spouses or offspring in undertakings capable of raising doubts on their integrity during their career.

Was it wrong for the petitioner’s counsel to have raised the controversial objection? Surely not. It is a standard, if convenient, practice in litigations in any genuine democracy. Once the matter is raised and determined as in the instant case, the door closes against prospects of whingeing after the verdict. On this sensitive issue, justice has been dispensed without fear or favour. Justice Bulkachuwa has helped the situation by asserting her discretion. After all, following the dismissal of the allegation, she could have continued presiding over the trial of the election petition.

There was this other angle. A matter of trust was raised and instantly dealt with, while the judge voluntarily withdrew even without any fault on her side. Suppose Justice Bulkachuwa stayed on, flaunting her innocence inherent in the ruling, the Judge would have distracted public attention on himself, away from the trial of the election petition proper. In that situation, the election petition trial might have been prejudiced by irresponsible comments. We must not underestimate the importance of the election petition.

Should the spouse of a serving judge refrain from participation in politics? That is at some stage unrealistic. However, ordinarily, discretion should have been better exercised. No judge will ever taint himself or allow himself to be tainted deliberately by political partisanship from any quarters but the same judge, as in this case, cannot escape being eventually rightly or wrongly faulted even if conveniently for the real or imagined conduct of his spouse, ironically in the exercise of the spouse’s fundamental human rights assured under Nigerian Constitution to associate or hold or express views on and for politics.

When such a situation arises, necessary sacrifice must be made as Justice Bulkachuwa has done for Nigeria.

Meanwhile, the overall lesson must not be lost, especially the family of judges. Whatever company they keep, however they conduct themselves, whatever views they hold privately or publicly do not end with them. Innocently waiting as victims or beneficiaries are the judges themselves as Justice Bulkachuwa would testify.

Rapheal

Rapheal

Related Posts

Nigerian destiny in hands of the people
Columns

Nigerian destiny in hands of the people

27th January 2023
The economy and social investment programme
Columns

The change Nigerians need

27th January 2023
Primaries: INEC insists on June 3
Editorial

INEC’s assurance on 2023 polls

27th January 2023
Next Post
Okorocha to VON DG: I still hold the ace in APC South East

Imo West: Legal battle shifts to Court of Appeal

I’m ready to submit to Ogun  people’s will, aspirations –Abiodun

I’m ready to submit to Ogun people’s will, aspirations –Abiodun

CAC applauds National Assembly on passage of Companies and Allied Matters Bill

Ninth NASS leadership: The case for merit

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Highlights

Sanwo-Olu signs N1.76 trillion budget into law

Bank customers groan over scarcity of new Naira notes 

Osun tribunal sacks Adeleke as gov, says Oyetola won guber poll

INEC fixes mock voter accreditation for Feb 4 

Awards Winners 2022

The Sun Awards 2022: Behold, Pride of the Nation

Trending

The Sun honours Ugwuanyi, Mele Kyari, Wike, Ikpeazu, Diri, Igbinedion, Haruna, Moghalu, opm go, Ojikutu, Opara, Pitan today
Cover

The Sun honours Ugwuanyi, Mele Kyari, Wike, Ikpeazu, Diri, Igbinedion, Haruna, Moghalu, opm go, Ojikutu, Opara, Pitan today

28th January 2023
0

• Ishaku, Bagudu’s wife, Ume, Ezeife, Mercy Johnson-Okojie Onumah, Okoye, Lamido, Mbisiogu, Ekeoma, Chukwudozie, Igwe, Uzochukwu also...

Abia-North 2023: Kalu kicks off re-election quest, unveils agriculture devt agenda 

Abia-North 2023: Kalu kicks off re-election quest, unveils agriculture devt agenda 

28th January 2023
Again, train derails in Abuja 

Again, train derails in Abuja 

28th January 2023
Sanwo-Olu signs N1.76 trillion budget into law

Sanwo-Olu signs N1.76 trillion budget into law

28th January 2023
Banks customers lament limited access to new Naira in Kebbi

Bank customers groan over scarcity of new Naira notes 

28th January 2023
ADVERTISEMENT

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • The Sun honours Ugwuanyi, Mele Kyari, Wike, Ikpeazu, Diri, Igbinedion, Haruna, Moghalu, opm go, Ojikutu, Opara, Pitan today
  • Abia-North 2023: Kalu kicks off re-election quest, unveils agriculture devt agenda 
  • Again, train derails in Abuja 
  • Sanwo-Olu signs N1.76 trillion budget into law
  • Bank customers groan over scarcity of new Naira notes 
  • Osun tribunal sacks Adeleke as gov, says Oyetola won guber poll
  • INEC fixes mock voter accreditation for Feb 4 
  • Awards Winners 2022
  • The Sun Awards 2022: Behold, Pride of the Nation
  • Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi: quiet and unassuming transformer
  • Mele Kyari:  oil management czar
  • Okezie Ikpeazu:  Advocate of made-in-Nigeraia products
  • Douye Diri: Portrait of miracle governor
  • Nyesom Wike: The courage to dare
  • Darius Ishaku:  Dogged political fighter
  • Ahmadu Fintiri:Transformation agent
  • Zainab Shinkafi-Bagudu: Passion for saving lives, uplifting the people
  • Olukayode Pitan: Banker with Midas touch
  • Brain drain: VC, MDCAN seek health systems strengthening
  • Sinatu Ojikutu: A business, political pathfinder

Categories

  • Abuja Metro
  • Anambra Watch
  • Arts
  • Broken Tongues
  • Business
  • Business Week
  • Cartoons
  • Citizen Joe
  • Columns
  • Cover
  • Culture
  • Duro Onabule
  • Editorial
  • Education Review
  • Effect
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Features
  • Femi Adesina
  • Food & Drinks
  • Frank Talk
  • Funke Egbemode
  • Gallery
  • Global Square by Kenneth Okonkwo
  • Health
  • Insights
  • Kalu Leadership Series
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Letters
  • Lifeline
  • Lifestyle
  • Literary Review
  • Marketing Matters
  • Muiz Banire
  • National
  • News
  • Offside Musings
  • Opinion
  • oriental news
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • PressClips
  • Public Sphere
  • Ralph Egbu
  • Shola Oshunkeye
  • Sideview
  • South-west Magazine
  • Sponsored Post
  • Sporting Sun
  • Sports
  • Sun Girl
  • Tea Time
  • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
  • The Sun Awards Live
  • The Sun TV
  • Thoughts & Talks
  • Time Out
  • Today's cover
  • Tola Adeniyi
  • Travel
  • Travel & Tourism
  • Trending
  • TSWeekend
  • Turf Game
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Views from Abroad
  • Voices
  • World
  • World News
  • About Us
  • Paper Ad Rate
  • Online Ad Rate
  • Change of Name
  • The Team
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
  • The Sun Foundation

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.