ADVERTISEMENT
The Sun Nigeria
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Nigeria
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Ley Your Dreams Come Alive – With FCMB Loans
Home Opinion

Border closure: Lessons from the World Bank

22nd October 2019
in Opinion
0
ERA warns on Lagos, World Bank infrastructure partnership
0
SHARES
238
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Jerome-Mario Utomi

IT is common knowledge that the Federal Government on August 20th, 2019, ordered the closure of Nigeria’s border with Benin Republic, citing massive smuggling activities taking place on that corridor as reason(s). Within this space also, Nigerians have listened with rapt attention to the Federal Government reel out how smuggling of rice and other communities from the neighbouring countries threatens the nation’s domestic rice production and frustrates the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)’s Anchor Borrowers Programme. Expectedly, the decision has elicited various comments from numerous stakeholders.

While Pro-border-closure expressed the view that though the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) protocol permits free movement of people, security must be prioritised, adding that the initiative aside from other gains have brought about  increase  to the nations’ revenue. Despite these ingrain “virtues and attributes” associated with the programme, Nigerians with critical interest have expressed concern about introducing such a policy without palliative, submitting that the policy in their estimation remains an unjust man-made code that neither squares with moral laws nor uplifts human personalities, as it possesses the capacity to render many Nigerians jobless and hungry.

Whatever the true position may be, like the next paragraph will illustrate, when one juxtaposes government narrative with the World Bank report on similar decision in June 2015 by the Nigeriain government, where it among other things excluded certain products eligibility for purposes of importation, it will further illustrate that FG’s present decision was more consistent with income generation and not in agreement with the harsh effect the policy may visit on the households.

Writing on the short-run impact of the import ban on poverty; the case of Nigeria (2008 to 2012), Andrew Dabalen and NgaThiBiet Nguyen, Lead Economist and Economist respectively, in the World Bank poverty and equity global practice, noted that  Nigerian Government uses food import prohibition as part of policies that seeks to protect existing domestic producers and reduce the country’s dependence on imports; without considering the fact that such policies have negative effects on net customers of such products due to higher prices.The World Bank in that report particularly noted that with 70% of poor households’ budget spent on food, and about 13% of the total budget devoted to products subject to import-banned, poor households is vulnerable to such trade policies. Prices of some imports prohibited food products are found to be higher than what they will in the absence of such bans.

During this period (2008 to 2012), ‘products that make about 13% of the household budget were subject to import ban. And the unintended consequences of such a policy stand on net consumers of products subject to import bans- particularly, the impact on prices of banned products and welfare of households who are net consumers.

They empirically established  that  prices of products that were subject to import prohibition between 2008 and 2012 were on average 29% higher in Nigeria than in Ghana and Senegal, and therefore advised that elimination of import bans would result in welfare gains for the population (Nigerians).

The magnitude of the estimate, the report added, differ by the country or countries used as benchmarks. On average National poverty, measured as those living below the international poverty line of 1.25dollars, could be lower by 2.6 percentage point, if Ghana is used as a benchmark country while suggesting that removal of import bans would lead to 2.9 percentage point reduction in rural poverty.

These findings in my views seems puzzling, and, the analysis demonstrates a direct relationship with what the vast majority of Nigerians currently experience as a result of the Federal Government closure of Nigeria’s borders

Substantially, this piece is not against border closure if it is aimed at greater good for greater number. Also, the purpose is not to illogically criticize the policy but to objectively understand the basic reason(s) responsible for the policy and what made it seemingly attractive to the FG; and possibly challenge those‘fundamental’ assumptions.

Interestingly, one of the best ways to achieve these is by finding the answer to; why this is coming at a time when the agricultural sector is not yet viable enough to carter for those consumption gaps created by the border closure? Why is the FG coming up with such decision at a time when unemployment rate in the country  is going by the National Bureau Statistics (NBS), 2019 report is presently at 23.1 per cent,  underemployment rate of 16.6 per cent and expected to reach an all-time high of  33.5 per cent by 2020.

Aside from the challenge posed by unemployment which makes the unemployed and underemployed a threat to the few that are employed, one of the incongruities of this situation is the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Sabo Nanono’s recent declaration during media a briefing to mark World Food Day in Abuja. That Nigeria is not in jeopardy of a food crisis or hunger as the Nation is producing enough to feed ourselves.  This cannot be further from the truth. Regardless of what others may say, there is hunger in the land and it is obvious. The price of rice and other commodities which have astronomically gone up in the market occasioned by the boarder-closure and stands as a telling proof to this assertion.

In many ways, the present administration may have a sincere desire to move the nation forward, but there are two major militating factors. First, there is no clear definition of our problem as a nation, the goals to be achieved, or the means chosen to address the problems and to achieve the goals. Secondly, the system has virtually no consideration for connecting the poor with good means of livelihood-food, job and security. This is the only possible explanations for this situation. To solve this lingering challenge, we must as a nation start looking for ways to developing/implementing plans and policies that will lead to price stability, high employment, effective regulation, trade and availability of finance for business.

As the debate rages, the Federal Government may go on with the closure as it appears socio-economically alluring. But one thing is sure; the potential harsh impact on Nigerians will be high. The choice is left for the FG to make.

Jerome-Mario writes from Lagos via [email protected]

Rapheal

Rapheal

Related Posts

Nigeria must not allow religious war  –Bishop Hammawa
Opinion

Nigeria must not allow religious war –Bishop Hammawa

24th June 2022
The economy and social investment programme
Columns

Constitutional backing for power rotation

24th June 2022
Opinion

Ndigbo need a consensus

24th June 2022
Next Post

WABU president lauds GOtv on ‘Boxing Night Mini’

Sanwo-Olu, Dare, others for Lagos Open Tennis grand finale

France-born Nigerian star, Hemery, Indian, Bhatia, win Lagos Open Tennis 2019

NBBF tasks corporate organisations on sports investment

Zenith Bank Women’s Basketball League Final 8: FirstBank, MFM, Dolphins, others jostle for semifinal tickets

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Highlights

Ekiti: Abducted retired chief pharmacist regains freedom after paying N4.5 million ransom

Flood washes away 30 shops in Anambra market

17 Ghanaian athletes in Nigeria for World Athletics Championship, Commonwealth trials

Buhari hails Sanwo-Olu’s visionary leadership at 57

NECO debunks rumours of postponement of 2022 SSCE school-based exams

Anambra: 30-year-old man rapes 75-year-old woman

Trending

Ondo: Governor issues EO on compulsory use of CCTV in public spaces
National

Ondo: Governor issues EO on compulsory use of CCTV in public spaces

25th June 2022
0

From Bamigbola Gbolagunte, Akure Ondo State Governor Rotimi Akeredolu has signed an Executive Order (EO) for the...

Malami mandates Khadimiyya groups to work for APC success

Malami mandates Khadimiyya groups to work for APC success

25th June 2022
Osinachi: Remains of singer interred in Abia home town

Osinachi: Remains of singer interred in Abia home town

25th June 2022
Ekiti: Abducted retired chief pharmacist regains freedom after paying N4.5 million ransom

Ekiti: Abducted retired chief pharmacist regains freedom after paying N4.5 million ransom

25th June 2022
Flood washes away 30 shops in Anambra market

Flood washes away 30 shops in Anambra market

25th June 2022
ADVERTISEMENT

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • Ondo: Governor issues EO on compulsory use of CCTV in public spaces
  • Malami mandates Khadimiyya groups to work for APC success
  • Osinachi: Remains of singer interred in Abia home town
  • Ekiti: Abducted retired chief pharmacist regains freedom after paying N4.5 million ransom
  • Flood washes away 30 shops in Anambra market
  • 17 Ghanaian athletes in Nigeria for World Athletics Championship, Commonwealth trials
  • Buhari hails Sanwo-Olu’s visionary leadership at 57
  • NECO debunks rumours of postponement of 2022 SSCE school-based exams
  • Anambra: 30-year-old man rapes 75-year-old woman
  • INEC bows to public pressure, extends voter registration deadline
  • Edo: Paediatrician under police investigation for alleged child abuse
  • CBN takes eNaira sensitisation to Tejuosho, Balogun traders
  • Nnamani condoles Obaigbena over mother’s death
  • South African Investor to establish 5,600 megawatts solar power project in Kebbi
  • How governor Yahaya Bello injected life into Kogi tertiary institutions – Commissioner of Education
  • UK: Defiant Boris Johnson says he won’t change despite election woes
  • Pfizer says tweaked COVID-19 shots boost omicron protection
  • 2022 internal examination begins Monday – NECO
  • Groups in Spain and Morocco push for border deaths inquiry
  • French lawmakers want abortion rights in constitution

Categories

  • Abuja Metro
  • Anambra Watch
  • Arts
  • Broken Tongues
  • Business
  • Business Week
  • Cartoons
  • Citizen Joe
  • Columns
  • Cover
  • Culture
  • Duro Onabule
  • Editorial
  • Education Review
  • Effect
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Features
  • Femi Adesina
  • Food & Drinks
  • Frank Talk
  • Funke Egbemode
  • Gallery
  • Global Square by Kenneth Okonkwo
  • Health
  • Insights
  • Kalu Leadership Series
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Letters
  • Lifeline
  • Lifestyle
  • Literary Review
  • Marketing Matters
  • Muiz Banire
  • National
  • News
  • Offside Musings
  • Opinion
  • oriental news
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • PressClips
  • Public Sphere
  • Ralph Egbu
  • Shola Oshunkeye
  • Sideview
  • South-west Magazine
  • Sponsored Post
  • Sporting Sun
  • Sports
  • Sun Girl
  • Tea Time
  • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
  • The Sun Awards Live
  • The Sun TV
  • Thoughts & Talks
  • Time Out
  • Today's cover
  • Tola Adeniyi
  • Travel
  • Travel & Tourism
  • Trending
  • TSWeekend
  • Turf Game
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Views from Abroad
  • Voices
  • World
  • World News
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Paper Ad Rate
  • Online Ad Rate
  • The Team
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

Posting....