ADVERTISEMENT
The Sun Nigeria
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Nigeria
No Result
View All Result
Home Columns

FCT CJ, Kalu and EFCC’s ‘forum shopping’ move

20th October 2016
in Columns
0
FCT CJ, Kalu and EFCC’s ‘forum shopping’ move
0
SHARES
71
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) had surreptitiously presented an application to The Chief Judge of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) to transfer Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CR/56/2007: Federal Republic of Nigeria V. Dr. Orji Uzor Kalu & 2 others, pending at Federal High Court No. 5, Abuja, to another judge sitting at Federal High Court, Lagos Division, nominated by EFCC. The EFCC application was neither made available to us, as counsel to Udeh Jones Udeogu and Slok Nigeria Ltd., the 2nd and 3rd defendants, nor to the 2nd and 3rd defendants personally.
It will be recalled that after the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal of the 1st and 2nd defendants, the court ordered that the charge be heard on merit. Our clients, in obedience to the order of the Supreme Court, appeared before the Federal High Court No. 5, Abuja, where it had assigned the matter and took their plea on September 27, 2016. All the defendants pleaded not guilty to all the 34 counts of the charge. The case was with consent of all the counsels in the matter and subject to the convenience of the court adjourned for hearing to December 6, 7 & 8, 2016. It may interest you to know that Rotimi Jacobs, Esq (SAN), counsel to EFCC, was present in court. He did not raise any objection before the trial court for the adjournment of this case to the said dates for hearing.
Our clients are, therefore, surprised and deeply shocked at the application of EFCC for transfer of this case and have instructed us to raise an objection on their behalf to the said application. We submit, with profound respect that the application of EFCC to the FCT CJ would infringe on our clients’ right to fair hearing/trial and tantamounts to forum shopping, which our law frowns at.
In Ibori Y. FRN (2009) All FWLR pt 487 p. 159 at 189, a case similar to the instant charge, the Court of Appeal held: “In this case, if a reasonable man is told that the appellants were arraigned before a court in Kaduna for offences allegedly committed in Delta State, and on the day they were granted ball after two months in prison custody, the court gave them one week to prepare their defence, would he be able to say that they were treated fairly by that court?
“How would the reasonable man see it if he is also told that within that one week, that appellants were expected to brief their lawyers and see to the movement of about 250 witnesses and volumes of vital documents from Delta State to a court in Kaduna that the EFCC handpicked to try them? Surely, any reasonable man would say that proceeding with their trial in that court would jeopardise the appellants’ right to a fair hearing/trial. The major plank of the appellants’ contention is that the presiding judge was not designated to hear EFCC cases and for the prosecution to seek him out and file the charge directly before him is forum shopping. Forum shopping occurs when a party attempts to have his action tried in a particular court or jurisdiction where he feels he will receive the most favourable judgment or verdict.”
Secondly, the offences upon which the defendants were charged to court were allegedly committed in Umuahia, Abia State, and not in Lagos. It would work hardship on our clients to go to Lagos with their witnesses and defence lawyers to defend this matter.
Thirdly, the EFCC application for transfer was not made in good faith. The said application will neither promote the end of justice nor be in the interest of public peace, as required by section 98 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015.
We respectfully urge your Lordship to discountenance this application for transfer made by EFCC and allow the matter to proceed to trial in Federal High Court No. 5 Abuja, as earlier adjourned. However, if, in the unlikely event, the FCT CJ may wish to consider this application, it behooves us to draw his attention to Section 98 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015, which made it mandatory that such an application should be referred to an independent body, comprising of three reputable legal practitioners for investigation before he could exercise his discretion on the matter.
We respectfully pray his lordship to be guided by the law and not to act at the behest of the EFCC on this matter in order not to scandalise the judiciary.

• Akuma is of the Chief Solo Akuma (SAN) & Associates, Mabushi District, Abuja

court-symbol

sunnews

sunnews

Related Posts

Insecurity: Matawalle leads operation against bandits
Columns

Consequencies of planned defection of Zamfara gov to APC

6th April 2021
Niggling diplomatic disputes with Ghana
Columns

Attitude change alone won’t fix election fraud

6th April 2021
End of an error
Columns

Doctors’ strike: Non-agreement agreement

6th April 2021
Next Post
Ijaw group demands justice for slain 3SC player

Ijaw group demands justice for slain 3SC player

Ahead Germany clash: Dream Team issues Dalung  red card

2016 Glo-CAF Awards: Iheanacho, Mikel, Musa’s nominations delight Nigerians

Russia 2018 World Cup qualifier: FIFA names Gambian ref for Nigeria, Algeria clash

Russia 2018 World Cup qualifier: FIFA names Gambian ref for Nigeria, Algeria clash

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Highlights

NiMet 3-day forecast: Expect sunshine, thunderstorms

FG receives India’s 100,000 doses of Covishield vaccines

Onyema completes tenure as NSE’s CEO

COVID-19: Why states were directed to halt vaccination halfway – FG

FG’ ll fish out criminals and boost security around custodial centres – Aregbesola

Bandits kill 8, injure 4 in Kaduna

Trending

FG: N31bn spent to fight COVID-19 in 4 months
Cover

Don’t take AstraZeneca, Johnson and Johnson vaccines together, FG warns

7th April 2021
0

From Juliana Taiwo-Obalonye, Abuja The Federal Government has explained why it asked all the states administering the...

Nigeria lost a Patriot, Progressive and Audacious Citizen in Odumakin – Ralph Nwosu, ADC, National Chairman

Nigeria lost a Patriot, Progressive and Audacious Citizen in Odumakin – Ralph Nwosu, ADC, National Chairman

6th April 2021
20th NSF opens formally with display of Edo culture

20th NSF opens formally with display of Edo culture

6th April 2021
2020: NiMet warns disaster managers to prepare for excess rainfall events

NiMet 3-day forecast: Expect sunshine, thunderstorms

6th April 2021
FG receives India’s 100,000 doses of Covishield vaccines

FG receives India’s 100,000 doses of Covishield vaccines

6th April 2021

Follow us on social media:

Categories

  • Abuja Metro
  • Arts
  • Broken Tongues
  • Business
  • Business Week
  • Cartoons
  • Citizen Joe
  • Columns
  • Cover
  • Culture
  • Duro Onabule
  • Editorial
  • Education Review
  • Effect
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Features
  • Femi Adesina
  • Food & Drinks
  • Frank Talk
  • Funke Egbemode
  • Gallery
  • Global Square by Kenneth Okonkwo
  • Health
  • Insights
  • Kalu Leadership Series
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Letters
  • Lifeline
  • Lifestyle
  • Literary Review
  • Marketing Matters
  • Muiz Banire
  • National
  • News
  • Offside Musings
  • Opinion
  • oriental news
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • PressClips
  • Public Sphere
  • Ralph Egbu
  • Shola Oshunkeye
  • Sideview
  • South-west Magazine
  • Sponsored Post
  • Sporting Sun
  • Sports
  • Sun Girl
  • Tea Time
  • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
  • The Sun Awards Live
  • The Sun TV
  • Thoughts & Talks
  • Time Out
  • Today's cover
  • Tola Adeniyi
  • Travel
  • Travel & Tourism
  • Trending
  • TSWeekend
  • Turf Game
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Views from Abroad
  • Voices
  • World
  • World News
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Paper Ad Rate
  • Online Ad Rate
  • The Team
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist