ADVERTISEMENT
The Sun Nigeria
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Nigeria
No Result
View All Result
Home National

Kogi: Tribunal affirms election of Governor Bello

Wada heads to Court of Appeal

23rd May 2020
in National
0
Kogi: Tribunal affirms election of Governor Bello

Kogi State Governor Yahaya Bello

0
SHARES
87
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Godwin Tsa, Abuja

The Kogi State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Abuja in a 2-to-1 split decision has affirmed the declaration and return of Yahaya Bello by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as the validly elected governor of Kogi State.

The majority judgment delivered by the Chairman of Tribunal, Justice Kashim Kaigama, dismissed the petition brought by the Peoples’ Democratic Party (PDP) and its candidate in the November 16 governorship election, Engineer Musa Wada, against the outcome of the election for lacking in merit.

But in a swift reaction, counsel to the petitioners, Jibril Okutepa, SAN, has vowed to challenge the judgment at the Court of Appeal.

Justice Kiagama with another member of the three-man panel, Justice Baraka Wali, dismissed the petition on the grounds that the petitioners failed to prove any grounds for their petition.

He awarded the cost of N500,000 against the petitioners in favour of the respondents.

However, in his dissenting judgment, Justice Ohimai Ovbiagele upheld the petitioners’ case by nullifying the results in seven out of the 21 local government areas in the state.

He ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to withdraw the certificate of return issued to governor Bello and ordered the electoral body to conduct a fresh election in seven local governments within three months.

Wada and his political party had in their petition contested the outcome of the governorship election in seven out of the 21 Local Government Areas of the state.

They are Adavi, Ajakuta Kabba/Bunnu; Okehi; Okene; Lokoja and Olamaboro Local government Areas of the state.

The petitioners complain that the governorship election in these local governments was characterised by corrupt practices, irregularities, over-voting, violence by armed men and other forms of electoral malpractices.

But in its majority judgment, the Tribunal held that the petitioners had through their witnesses and documentary evidence failed to established their claim.

Justice Kiagama in his judgment held that most of the evidence adduced by the petitioner’s witnesses were unreliable and hearsay.

Although the petitioners had through their lead counsel, Jibril Okutepa, SAN, argued that the election be voided by corrupt practices in breach of the provisions of the Electoral Act, 2010 (as amended), which substantially affected it’s results, the Tribunal held that they have failed to prove the allegations.

The Tribunal equally dismissed the evidence adduced by the forensic expert, Prof Tanko Ishaya, and the Deputy Vice Chancellor(Academics), University of Jos.

Prof Ishaya, who testified as Petitioners Witness (Pw19) is a professor of Computer Science with a Mathematics background and specialisation and experience in Data Engineering, Computer Security and Forensics.

The Tribunal held that it is not bound by his evidence on the grounds that he ‘went beyond the order of the court as contained in the supeona issued to him.

‘He cannot be counting and re-counting the ballot papers. That is the exclusive duty of an electoral officer or a represented of INEC.

The Tribunal further held that ‘Pw19, the forensic expert, was hired by the petitioners to do his job and he could not prove allegations of over-voting. His evidence requires collaboration by other witnesses and relevant electoral materials “and this was lacking.

‘The Tribunal is not bound to swallow his evidence hook, line and sinker, but to evaluate same to see if it has any probative value.’

Citing some case laws, the Tribunal held that the ‘court are enjoined to be circumspect while acting on expert opinions. This is because there is the likelihood of bias in favour of those that engaged them as he who pays the pipper dictates the tune.

‘In the final analysis, after going through the evidence of the witnesses and documentary evidence before us, we are unable to agree with the Petitioners that the election of the 2nd responded (Yahaya Bello) be nullified as the Petitioners have failed to prove the allegations contained in the petition.

‘Accordingly, the petition is hereby dismissed for lacking in merit. The election and declaration of the 2nd respondent as the validly elected governor of Kogi State is hereby affirmed.’

But in his minority judgment, Justice Ovbiagele disagreed with his colleagues and upheld the petition. He predicated his judgment on the evidence of Pw19 which he held was valid, unchallenged and uncontroverted by the respondents.

‘Failure to controvert the evidence of Pw19 was fatal to the case of the respondents and the court have no reason to doubt his evidence.

‘His testimony was straight forward, accurate, unbroken and in consistent with the evidence that the election was deeply flawed.

‘There is no reason to doubt the veracity of his evidence which was not contradicted by therespondents. Besides, the documents presented by him are valid and admissible.

‘His evidence was collaborated by other witnesses who testified on the side of the petitioners, who demonstrated massive rigging and electoral violence.

‘On the whole, I find that the 2nd respondent was not validly elected as the governor of Kogi and I make an order directing that his certificate of return issued to him by INEC to be withdrawn and a fresh election conducted within three months.’

Click Here>>>>>>7 Natural Herbs to Finally End Premature Ejaculation and Weak Erection<<<<<<

Click Here>>>>>>Anti-kidnap and anti-theft device for tracking and listening<<<<<<

David

David

Sun News Online team

Related Posts

More trouble for ex-Gov Yari as court grants ICPC’s request to freeze his bank accounts
National

Court dismisses exam fraud charges against Adeleke’s co-accused

27th January 2021
Freed Shiites: Kaduna High Court judge not one of us, says lawyers
National

Court orders final forfeiture of ex-Gov. Yari’s money in 2 banks

27th January 2021
14 killed, 8 injured in Kano road crash
National

Commercial bus crushes man to death while running from task force in Lagos

27th January 2021
Next Post
Sallah: Matawalle warns bandits to embrace peace or face military onslaught

Sallah: Matawalle warns bandits to embrace peace now

Islamic cleric stopped from marrying 16-year-old girl as 9th wife

Islamic cleric stopped from marrying 16-year-old girl as 9th wife

Eid al-Fitr: Adeyeye congratulates Muslim faithful, seeks prayers for end of COVID-19

Eid al-Fitr: Adeyeye congratulates Muslim faithful, seeks prayers for end of COVID-19

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Highlights

China and the end of poverty: Implications for Africa

Whither the right to health in Nigeria?

How to link your other phone numbers with NIMC mobile app

Court dismisses exam fraud charges against Adeleke’s co-accused

Court orders final forfeiture of ex-Gov. Yari’s money in 2 banks

Commercial bus crushes man to death while running from task force in Lagos

Trending

Reactions to my series on Atiku winning 2019 poll (3)
Columns

Security: Buhari, be careful with Ondo State & S-W in general

27th January 2021
0

The invasion of the South-West in recent years by herdsmen said to be Fulani which escalated to...

Higher philosophy of christian marriage (12)

Higher realities of spiritual life (3)

27th January 2021
Trouble for tax evaders as FG inaugurates Project Lighthouse committee

Don’t sell public assets

27th January 2021

China and the end of poverty: Implications for Africa

27th January 2021

Whither the right to health in Nigeria?

27th January 2021
ADVERTISEMENT

Follow us on social media:

Categories

  • Abuja Metro
  • Arts
  • Broken Tongues
  • Business
  • Business Week
  • Cartoons
  • Citizen Joe
  • Columns
  • Cover
  • Culture
  • Duro Onabule
  • Editorial
  • Education Review
  • Effect
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Features
  • Femi Adesina
  • Food & Drinks
  • Frank Talk
  • Funke Egbemode
  • Gallery
  • Global Square by Kenneth Okonkwo
  • Health
  • Insights
  • Kalu Leadership Series
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Letters
  • Lifeline
  • Lifestyle
  • Literary Review
  • Marketing Matters
  • Muiz Banire
  • National
  • News
  • Offside Musings
  • Opinion
  • oriental news
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • PressClips
  • Public Sphere
  • Ralph Egbu
  • Shola Oshunkeye
  • Sideview
  • South-west Magazine
  • Sponsored Post
  • Sporting Sun
  • Sports
  • Sun Girl
  • Tea Time
  • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
  • The Sun Awards Live
  • The Sun TV
  • Thoughts & Talks
  • Time Out
  • Today's cover
  • Tola Adeniyi
  • Travel
  • Travel & Tourism
  • Trending
  • TSWeekend
  • Turf Game
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Views from Abroad
  • Voices
  • World
  • World News
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Paper Ad Rate
  • Online Ad Rate
  • The Team
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist