ADVERTISEMENT
The Sun Nigeria
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Nigeria
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Ley Your Dreams Come Alive – With FCMB Loans
Home Columns

Umeh vs. Ekwunife: Understanding the issues before the Tribunal

24th August 2019
in Columns
0
Atiku: Who wants to be a Nigerian?
0
SHARES
320
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

This article is by no means an attempt to pre determine the issue before the Anambra State National and State Assembly Election Tribunal in the matter between Distinguished Senator Victor Umeh of the All Progressive Grand Alliance (APGA) and the candidate of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Sen. Uche Ekwunife.

This is a case that has generated lots of attention and disinformation, hence, it becomes necessary that the issues in contention are further clarified for the benefit of the public. This is irrespective of where the pendulum of justice swings at the end of the day.

Umeh’s main contention bothers on violation of extant provisions of the 1999 Constitution as amended and the Electoral Act 2010 as amended. His contention has nothing to do with how PDP conducted her primary election or the qualification of their candidate, but that the party fielded a candidate who ought not to have been fielded having not participated in the primary election process.

Are you a Man 40 yrs and above? Do not miss the Vital Information, it goes off in 2 days! CLICH HERE to READ .

This position will be best appreciated bearing in mind the Supreme Court clarification of the meaning of ‘Election’ in Agbaso v Ohakim.  The court said election is ‘not an event but a process leading to an event.  It is necessary that everything connected with the process leading to the election including the actual election and its aftermath come within the jurisdiction of the election tribunal.”

Unfortunately this salient clarification by Supreme Court is lost on political parties and office seekers intent on violating the electoral process with the hope that the end will justify the means.  The courts over time have frowned at these violations by desperate politicians. The position of the courts in interpreting the Constitution and the Electoral Act has not changed as it accords the same value to the process as well as the event. To the courts, the means must justify the end, and not otherwise.

Recall that one of the major issues bedeviling our democracy is the impunity of the political class who are not willing to play by the rules. They have shown scant respect for the constitution, the Electoral Act and the rules of their own political party with regards to the process of nomination of candidates.

Breaking!!! Earn up to N2 - N3 million monthly GUARANTEED (all paid in US Dollars). No training or refereal required. Do business with top USA companies like Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, IBM, Netflix, Zoom, etc. Learn more .

To curb this mischief, and in particular the excesses of the political godfathers, and to sanitize the political process, Section 141 of the Electoral Act 2010 as amended having set aside and overridden the decision in Amaechi v INEC provided that a ‘person to be declared and returned as a winner of an election by court or a tribunal must have been a person who have participated as a candidate in all stages of the election starting from his nomination as a candidate to the actual voting’.  This is the position of the law and it has not changed, hence the courts are bound to ensure that the political parties comply with the law, particularly the law on how each political party fields its candidates in an election.

(1)    Did the PDP candidate in the 2019 Anambra Central Senatorial District election participate in all stages of the election as required by Section 141 of the Electoral Act?  What does the Act mean by ‘All Stages’ of the election?

Premature Ejaculation & "Small Joystick" Resolved in 7Days... Click Here For Details .

(2)    Can a candidate validly nominated by a political party as its candidate in a particular election be nominated by a rival party as a candidate for the same position in the same election? That is, can a candidate be a beneficiary of multiple nominations in the same election?

On issue one, Undoubtedly, Section 87(1) of the Electoral Act provides that a political party seeking to nominate candidates for elections under this Act shall hold primaries for aspirants for all elective positions”.

In this case, the candidate fielded by PDP did not participate in the primary election held by PDP on 2nd October 2019 or any other primary election conducted by the party on any other date for the purpose of nominating its candidate for the election in question.

100% Natural Herbs to Finally End Premature Ejaculation, Weak Erection and Small Manhood. >>>Click Here for Details<<< .

By her admission under cross examination, the PDP candidate was at the time of the PDP primary election a member of the APC where she ran for the APC primary election and was returned by the party and was subsequently published by INEC as a candidate of APC for the Anambra Central Senatorial District Election. She remained in that position several weeks after the PDP primary election was concluded.

Section 285(13) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, as amended, provided that “An election tribunal or court shall not declare any person a winner at an election in which such a person has not fully participated in all the stages of the election.” Having not participated in the PDP primary can she be said to have participated in all stages of the election?

However, the PDP candidate purportedly resigned from APC and was nominated as substitute candidate of the Peoples Democratic Party on November 17, 2018.

While there is nothing wrong in being a substitute candidate, such a candidate must be eligible for substitution, meaning the candidate must have participated in the primary election which is a condition precedent.

The Supreme Court said this much in the case of Abiodun Faleke v INEC, where it ruled as follows “By virtue of section 177(c) of the 1999 Constitution, a person seeking to contest an election into the office of Governor of a State must be a member of a political party and must be sponsored by that party. Furthermore, he must have participated in the party’s primary elections. The provisions of Section 181 (1) of the Constitution would have become applicable. However, in the circumstances of the case, with the election held on 21/11/2015 being declared inconclusive and the Governorship candidate having died, the appellant could not metamorphose into the Governorship candidate. His status remained that of a Deputy Governorship candidate to a deceased Governorship candidate, particularly as he did not participate in the party’s primaries, which is a pre-condition for anyone seeking elective office.

The case of Ehilanwo v INEC and the recent case of APC Zamfara further rests on all fours in the instant case. In the case of Zamfara for instance, the court in one fell swoop and without mercy disqualified the entire APC candidates in the 2019 general elections on the grounds that they did not participate in primary elections which is condition precedent.

Note that the Zamfara case comprised of the governorship candidate who polled nearly NINE HUNDRED THOUSAND votes, all senatorial candidates, all House of Representatives candidates and all State House of Assembly candidates on the account of non-compliance with the electoral process.

On whether a validly nominated candidate of a political party for a particular election can be nominated by another party for the same election, I submit that the recent judgment voiding the candidature of Hon Uche Nwosu as governorship candidate in Imo State serves as a useful guide.

Justice Inyang of the Federal High Court Abuja voided the candidature of Nwosu on the ground of double nomination by two political parties for the same election, which are All Progressives Congress (APC) and Action Alliance (AA) in violation of Section 37 of the same Act. Uche Nwosu participated in the APC primaries held October 6, 2018 and was subsequently nominated as the party’s governorship candidate. While holding the APC ticket the time of primary lapsed and he became nominated as the AA candidate.

When you have done things illegally it is not the duty of the court to aid you to benefit from illegality.  Laws are made to be obeyed by all concerned, including political parties. Therefore, the law shall take its course where a party fails, neglects or refuses  to comply with the mandatory provisions of the Electoral Act on nomination and submission of names of its candidate for a general election. Such a political party shall be deemed or taken in law to have fielded no candidate in that particular election. See the case of APC v. Marafa. All eyes are now on the tribunal’s three wise men to render justice where it is due after considering all the facts of the matter.

Partner with me, let's get you making N500K to N500K a month! Skills open the doors to financial opportunities Click here to learn it .
Rapheal

Rapheal

Related Posts

Winning with the Nigerian spirit
Columns

Tears for breast cancer girl who just died

28th May 2022
Lagos judiciary again raises the bar on adr practice
Columns

Who is on the driver’s seat in ADR development?

28th May 2022
Atiku: Who wants to be a Nigerian?
Columns

Everybody agrees Nigeria is in bad shape

28th May 2022
Next Post
Lagos judiciary again raises the bar on adr practice

Mediation and the ease of doing international business

In search of ennobling leadership virtues in Nigeria (1)

The law of incorporated trustees as it affects churches, mosques, et al

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

Highlights

Senator Sani Musa wins Niger East senatorial primary

Kebbi APC primary: Sahabi wins Kalgo House Assembly ticket

Road to 2023: Tambuwal drops out of PDP presidential contest

Road to 2023: Jonathan absent as PDP begins national convention

Terrorism: Buhari endorses African standby force

Oshiomhole, 2 others emerge APC senatorial candidates in Edo

Trending

Lalong, Giwa, Diket Plang win candidacies for Plateau senatorial seats
Elections

Lalong, Giwa, Diket Plang win candidacies for Plateau senatorial seats

28th May 2022
0

From Gyang Bere, Jos Plateau State Governor Simon Lalong has clinched the APC ticket to run for...

Buhari congratulates Dare at 56

Buhari congratulates Dare at 56

28th May 2022
Deaths in Port Harcourt stampede saddening - Buhari

Deaths in Port Harcourt stampede saddening – Buhari

28th May 2022
Senator Sani Musa wins Niger East senatorial primary

Senator Sani Musa wins Niger East senatorial primary

28th May 2022
Kebbi APC primary: Sahabi wins Kalgo House Assembly ticket

Kebbi APC primary: Sahabi wins Kalgo House Assembly ticket

28th May 2022

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • Lalong, Giwa, Diket Plang win candidacies for Plateau senatorial seats
  • Buhari congratulates Dare at 56
  • Deaths in Port Harcourt stampede saddening – Buhari
  • Senator Sani Musa wins Niger East senatorial primary
  • Kebbi APC primary: Sahabi wins Kalgo House Assembly ticket
  • Road to 2023: Tambuwal drops out of PDP presidential contest
  • Road to 2023: Jonathan absent as PDP begins national convention
  • Terrorism: Buhari endorses African standby force
  • Oshiomhole, 2 others emerge APC senatorial candidates in Edo
  • Road to 2023: Atiku, Wike, Saraki in popularity contest at PDP convention
  • Groups push harder for creation of IACC
  • 2023: Akwa Ibom professionals drum support for Emmanuel
  • APC: Ogbu-Aguocha clinches Enugu East senatorial ticket
  • 2023 presidency: APC decision binding on me — ex Zamfara gov, Yerima
  • Kaduna children ask El-Rufai to provide wheelchairs, sign language interpreters for physically challenged colleagues
  • PDP convention: Plot against Wike dead on arrival – Group
  • Road to 2023: El-Rufai’s ex-Chief of Staff Dattijo clinches Kaduna Central Senate ticket
  • Road to 2023: APC aspirants, masses abort secret voting in Oyo North, demand direct primary
  • Don calls for joint funding of education in Nigeria
  • Crisis looms in Imo East APC senatorial primary as Akeredolu rejects consensus, insists on election

Categories

  • Abuja Metro
  • Anambra Watch
  • Arts
  • Broken Tongues
  • Business
  • Business Week
  • Cartoons
  • Citizen Joe
  • Columns
  • Cover
  • Culture
  • Duro Onabule
  • Editorial
  • Education Review
  • Effect
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Features
  • Femi Adesina
  • Food & Drinks
  • Frank Talk
  • Funke Egbemode
  • Gallery
  • Global Square by Kenneth Okonkwo
  • Health
  • Insights
  • Kalu Leadership Series
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Kunle Solaja
  • Letters
  • Lifeline
  • Lifestyle
  • Literary Review
  • Marketing Matters
  • Muiz Banire
  • National
  • News
  • Offside Musings
  • Opinion
  • oriental news
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • PressClips
  • Public Sphere
  • Ralph Egbu
  • Shola Oshunkeye
  • Sideview
  • South-west Magazine
  • Sponsored Post
  • Sporting Sun
  • Sports
  • Sun Girl
  • Tea Time
  • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
  • The Sun Awards Live
  • The Sun TV
  • Thoughts & Talks
  • Time Out
  • Today's cover
  • Tola Adeniyi
  • Travel
  • Travel & Tourism
  • Trending
  • TSWeekend
  • Turf Game
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Views from Abroad
  • Voices
  • World
  • World News
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Paper Ad Rate
  • Online Ad Rate
  • The Team
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Columns
    • Broken Tongues
    • Capital Matters
    • Diabetes Corner
    • Duro Onabule
    • Femi Adesina
    • Frank Talk
    • Funke Egbemode
    • Insights
    • Kalu Leadership Series
    • Kunle Solaja
    • Offside Musings
    • PressClips
    • Public Sphere
    • Ralph Egbu
    • Shola Oshunkeye
    • Sideview
    • The Flipside – Eric Osagie
    • Tola Adeniyi
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • The Sun TV
  • Sporting Sun

© 2019 The Sun Nigeria - Managed by Netsera.

Posting....